Open Access
Review
Table 1
Baseline characteristics of the included studies.
Paper ID | First author | Year | Country/State | Number of participants | Number infected | Diagnostic method | Patients with diarrhea | Patients with CD4<200 | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Inungu J | 2000 | Louisiana | 6913 | 239 | Staining | NR | NR | [62] |
2 | Chokephaibulkit K | 2001 | Thailand | 82 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [31] |
3 | Gassama A | 2001 | Senegal | 318 | 15 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 49.70% | NR | [46] |
4 | Lebbad M | 2001 | Guinea-Bissau | 37 | 9 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [85] |
5 | Wiwanitkit V | 2001 | Thailand | 60 | 2 | Odine and Modified Trichromes | 46.70% | 41.70% | [174] |
6 | Brink AK | 2002 | Uganda | 358 | 18 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 70.10% | NR | [22] |
7 | Joshi M | 2002 | India | 94 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [70] |
8 | Kumar SS | 2002 | India | 150 | 14 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 66.70% | NR | [81] |
9 | Leav BA | 2002 | Congo | 101 | 25 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [84] |
10 | Mohandas K | 2002 | India | 120 | 13 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 67.50% | NR | [99] |
11 | Saksirisampant W | 2002 | Thailand | 156 | 20 | Ziehl-Nelson | NR | NR | [129] |
12 | Wanachiwanawin D | 2002 | Thailand | 95 | 3 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [168] |
13 | Adjei A | 2003 | Ghana | 21 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [4] |
14 | Arenas-Pinto A | 2003 | Venezuela | 304 | 45 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 71.40% | NR | [12] |
15 | Cama VA | 2003 | Peru | 2672 | 354 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [23] |
16 | Cranendonk R | 2003 | Malawi | 348 | 16 | Phenol-auramine-O-fluorescence | 49.80% | NR | [33] |
17 | Shenoy S | 2003 | India | 120 | 21 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [138] |
18 | Silva CV | 2003 | Brazil | 52 | 3 | Safranin/Methylene Blue | NR | NR | [142] |
19 | Singh A | 2003 | India | 100 | 47 | Staining | NR | NR | [143] |
20 | Carcamo C | 2004 | Peru | 294 | 39 | Modified Safranin | 50.00% | NR | [24] |
21 | Ribeiro PC | 2004 | Brazil | 75 | 7 | Safranin/Methylene Blue | NR | NR | [125] |
22 | Zali MR | 2004 | Iran | 206 | 3 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 13.60% | NR | [183] |
23 | Certad G | 2005 | Venezuela | 397 | 59 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 75.60% | NR | [26] |
24 | Guk SM | 2005 | Korea | 67 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [54] |
25 | Houpt ER | 2005 | Tanzania | 127 | 22 | IFA | 48.00% | NR | [58] |
26 | Lim YA | 2005 | Malaysia | 66 | 2 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 9.10% | NR | [89] |
27 | Marques FR | 2005 | Brazil | 94 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | NR | [91] |
28 | Pinlaor S | 2005 | Thailand | 78 | 9 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 32.10% | NR | [122] |
29 | Sadraei J | 2005 | India | 200 | 84 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 38.00% | 41.00% | [128] |
30 | Silva CV | 2005 | Brazil | 100 | 4 | Safranin/Methylene Blue, ELISA | 38.00% | NR | [141] |
31 | Tadesse A | 2005 | Ethiopia | 70 | 20 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [148] |
32 | Tumwine JK | 2005 | Uganda | 91 | 67 | IFA | NR | NR | [158] |
33 | Adhikari NA | 2006 | Nepal | 112 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [3] |
34 | Chhin S | 2006 | Cambodia | 80 | 36 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 50.00% | NR | [30] |
35 | Navarro-i-Martinez L | 2006 | Colombia | 103 | 6 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [102] |
36 | Oguntibeju OO | 2006 | Lesotho | 60 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 56.70% | NR | [109] |
37 | Sarfati C | 2006 | Cameroon | 154 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 28.60% | NR | [135] |
38 | de Oliveira-Silva MB | 2007 | Brazil | 359 | 31 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 70.20% | NR | [36] |
39 | Dwivedi KK | 2007 | India | 75 | 25 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 66.70% | NR | [40] |
40 | Hung CC | 2007 | Taiwan | 332 | 4 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 40.10% | [59] |
41 | Ramakrishnan K | 2007 | India | 80 | 23 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [124] |
42 | Rossit AR | 2007 | Brazil | 55 | 34 | ELISA | 16.40% | NR | [127] |
43 | Stark D | 2007 | Australia | 628 | 14 | Modified iron-hematoxylin | 100.00% | NR | [145] |
44 | Taherkhani H | 2007 | Iran | 75 | 20 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [149] |
45 | Vignesh R | 2007 | India | 245 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [164] |
46 | Bachur TP | 2008 | Brazil | 582 | 47 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [17] |
47 | Gupta S | 2008 | India | 113 | 9 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 30.10% | NR | [56] |
48 | Jayalakshmi J | 2008 | India | 89 | 11 | Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | 100.00% | NR | [68] |
49 | Kaushik K | 2008 | India | 206 | 27 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | 48.10% | 32.50% | [75] |
50 | Nuchjangreed C | 2008 | Thailand | 46 | 2 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | 28.30% | NR | [107] |
51 | Raccurt CP | 2008 | Haiti | 74 | 45 | PCR | NR | NR | [123] |
52 | Tuli L | 2008 | India | 366 | 146 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | 64.50% | [156] |
53 | Werneck-Silva AL | 2008 | Brazil | 690 | 1 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [173] |
54 | Zaidah AR | 2008 | Malaysia | 59 | 9 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [182] |
55 | Zavvar M | 2008 | Iran | 35 | 21 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [184] |
56 | Assefa S | 2009 | Ethiopia | 214 | 43 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [14] |
57 | Daryani A | 2009 | Iran | 64 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [34] |
58 | Dillingham RA | 2009 | Haiti | 243 | 39 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 100.00% | [39] |
59 | Gautam H | 2009 | India | 43 | 7 | ELISA | NR | 100.00% | [47] |
60 | Kulkarni SV | 2009 | India | 137 | 16 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 47.40% | [80] |
61 | Kurniawan A | 2009 | Indonesia | 318 | 30 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [82] |
62 | Lule JR | 2009 | Uganda | 879 | 30 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 29.90% | [90] |
63 | Saksirisampant W | 2009 | Thailand | 90 | 31 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | 78.90% | NR | [130] |
64 | Uppal B | 2009 | India | 100 | 3 | ELISA | 50.00% | NR | [161] |
65 | Dehkordy AB | 2010 | Iran | 33 | 3 | ELISA | NR | NR | [38] |
66 | Getaneh A | 2010 | Ethiopia | 192 | 48 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [49] |
67 | Idris NS | 2010 | Indonesia | 22 | 1 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [61] |
68 | Kashyap B | 2010 | India | 64 | 8 | Safranin-methylene blue | NR | 48.40% | [74] |
69 | Tuli L | 2010 | India | 450 | 163 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | NR | [157] |
70 | Akinbo FO | 2011 | Nigeria | 2000 | 80 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 12.80% | [8] |
71 | Alemu A | 2011 | Ethiopia | 188 | 82 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [10] |
72 | Cardoso LV | 2011 | Brazil | 500 | 1 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 28.60% | NR | [25] |
73 | Erhabor O | 2011 | Nigeria | 105 | 3 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 24.80% | NR | [41] |
74 | Kucerova Z | 2011 | Russia | 46 | 19 | ELISA | NR | NR | [79] |
75 | Lim YA | 2011 | Malaysia | 122 | 27 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [88] |
76 | Ojurongbe O | 2011 | Nigeria | 96 | 52 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [112] |
77 | Patel SD | 2011 | India | 100 | 20 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 32.00% | NR | [118] |
78 | Santos RB | 2011 | Brazil | 1010 | 4 | Staining | NR | NR | [134] |
79 | Srisuphanunt M | 2011 | Thailand | 152 | 33 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | NR | [144] |
80 | Stensvold CR | 2011 | Denmark | 96 | 1 | Staining | NR | 13.50% | [146] |
81 | Boaitey YA | 2012 | Ghana | 500 | 70 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 51.60% | NR | [21] |
82 | Iqbal A | 2012 | Malaysia | 346 | 18 | PCR | NR | NR | [63] |
83 | Izadi M | 2012 | Iran | 47 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [65] |
84 | Jha AK | 2012 | India | 154 | 87 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 35.10% | [69] |
85 | Kange’the E | 2012 | Kenya | 155 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [72] |
86 | Khurana S | 2012 | India | 671 | 40 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | NR | [77] |
87 | Lehman LG | 2012 | Cameroon | 201 | 13 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 18.40% | NR | [86] |
88 | Masarat S | 2012 | India | 45 | 45 | Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | NR | [92] |
89 | Netor Velasquez J | 2012 | Argentina | 11 | 3 | PCR | NR | NR | [105] |
90 | Ojuromi OT | 2012 | Nigeria | 193 | 44 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 34.70% | NR | [111] |
91 | Pavie J | 2012 | France | 143 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 59.40% | 100.00% | [119] |
92 | Roka M | 2012 | Guinea | 260 | 24 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [126] |
93 | Sharma P | 2012 | India | 970 | 44 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [137] |
94 | Tian LG | 2012 | China | 302 | 25 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [153] |
95 | Vyas N | 2012 | India | 366 | 75 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 72.70% | NR | [166] |
96 | Wang L | 2013 | China | 683 | 10 | PCR | 44.50% | NR | [169] |
97 | Adamu H | 2013 | Ethiopia | 378 | 32 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 45.30% | NR | [2] |
98 | Agholi M | 2013 | Iran | 356 | 34 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 28.90% | 52.80% | [5] |
99 | Ahmed NH | 2013 | India | 242 | 40 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [6] |
100 | Akinbo FO | 2013 | Nigeria | 285 | 4 | PCR | 37.90% | 15.80% | [9] |
101 | Assis DC | 2013 | Brazil | 59 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 39.00% | NR | [15] |
102 | Ayinmode AB | 2013 | Nigeria | 132 | 8 | PCR | 59.80% | 13.60% | [16] |
103 | Bartelt LA | 2013 | South Africa | 193 | 146 | ELISA | NR | NR | [18] |
104 | Dash M | 2013 | India | 115 | 14 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 36.50% | [35] |
105 | Gupta K | 2013 | India | 100 | 4 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 19.00% | 32.00% | [55] |
106 | Janagond AB | 2013 | India | 100 | 2 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 68.00% | 30.00% | [67] |
107 | Rashmi KS | 2013 | India | 90 | 15 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [71] |
108 | Mathur MK | 2013 | India | 544 | 135 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 73.50% | NR | [93] |
109 | Mehta KD | 2013 | India | 100 | 2 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 24.00% | [94] |
110 | Missaye A | 2013 | Ethiopia | 272 | 2 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 10.70% | [96] |
111 | Mohanty I | 2013 | India | 250 | 13 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 80.00% | NR | [100] |
112 | Teklemariam Z | 2013 | Ethiopia | 371 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 20.20% | 27.00% | [151] |
113 | Tian LG | 2013 | China | 79 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 100.00% | [154] |
114 | Tiwari BR | 2013 | Nepal | 745 | 23 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 33.30% | 43.90% | [155] |
115 | Vyas N | 2013 | India | 75 | 11 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 42.70% | [167] |
116 | Zeynudin A | 2013 | Ethiopia | 91 | 8 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [185] |
117 | Adamu H | 2014 | Ethiopia | 520 | 140 | PCR | NR | NR | [1] |
118 | Blanco MA | 2014 | Guinea | 171 | 31 | PCR | NR | NR | [20] |
119 | Girma M | 2014 | Ethiopia | 268 | 92 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 90.30% | 69.80% | [52] |
120 | Omoruyi BE | 2014 | South Africa | 35 | 23 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | NR | [113] |
121 | Paboriboune P | 2014 | Laos | 137 | 9 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 43.10% | 100.00% | [115] |
122 | Parghi E | 2014 | India | 93 | 16 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 19.40% | [117] |
123 | Samie A | 2014 | South Africa | 106 | 30 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [132] |
124 | Shimelis T | 2014 | Ethiopia | 250 | 32 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [139] |
125 | Taye B | 2014 | Ethiopia | 316 | 3 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [150] |
126 | Uppal B | 2014 | India | 58 | 45 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen, ELISA | NR | 100.00% | [162] |
127 | Vouking MZ | 2014 | Cameroon | 207 | 15 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [165] |
128 | Wanyiri JW | 2014 | Kenya | 164 | 56 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | 42.70% | NR | [171] |
129 | Ahmed NH | 2015 | India | 142 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [7] |
130 | Angal L | 2015 | Malaysia | 131 | 5 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 18.30% | [11] |
131 | Asma I | 2015 | Malaysia | 346 | 43 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [13] |
132 | Fregonesi BM | 2015 | Brazil | 17 | 4 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [45] |
133 | Khalil S | 2015 | India | 200 | 15 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 50.00% | 50.00% | [76] |
134 | Kiros H | 2015 | Ethiopia | 399 | 23 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 16.80% | [78] |
135 | Mengist HM | 2015 | Ethiopia | 180 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [95] |
136 | Ojuromi OT | 2015 | Nigeria | 90 | 4 | PCR | 74.40% | NR | [110] |
137 | Oyedeji OA | 2015 | Nigeria | 52 | 10 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [114] |
138 | Pavlinac PB | 2015 | Kenya | 56 | 1 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [120] |
139 | Petrincová A | 2015 | Slovak Republic | 20 | 0 | PCR | NR | NR | [121] |
140 | Tellevik MG | 2015 | Tanzania | 33 | 8 | PCR | NR | NR | [152] |
141 | Wumba RD | 2015 | Congo | 242 | 13 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | 34.30% | NR | [177] |
142 | Zhang L | 2015 | China | 190 | 26 | ELISA | NR | 33.70% | [186] |
143 | Gholami R | 2016 | Iran | 53 | 4 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 100.00% | 100.00% | [51] |
144 | Hailu AW | 2016 | Ethiopia | 81 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [57] |
145 | Kaniyarakkal V | 2016 | India | 200 | 2 | Ziehl-Neelsen, Elisa | 45.50% | 100.00% | [73] |
146 | Kwakye-Nuako G | 2016 | Ghana | 50 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 46.00% | [83] |
147 | Mitra S | 2016 | India | 194 | 57 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [97] |
148 | Nsagha DS | 2016 | Cameroon | 300 | 132 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 39.30% | 25.30% | [106] |
149 | Salehi Sangani G | 2016 | Iran | 80 | 1 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | 100.00% | [131] |
150 | Shah S | 2016 | India | 45 | 6 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 60.00% | 100.00% | [136] |
151 | Shimelis T | 2016 | Ethiopia | 491 | 65 | Ziehl-Neelsen | 43.80% | 56.20% | [140] |
152 | Eshetu T | 2017 | Ethiopia | 223 | 7 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [42] |
153 | Gedle D | 2017 | Ethiopia | 323 | 19 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [48] |
154 | Ghafari R | 2017 | Iran | 250 | 27 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [50] |
155 | Irisarri-Gutierrez MJ | 2017 | Mozambique | 70 | 4 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [64] |
156 | Obateru O.A | 2017 | Nigeria | 238 | 131 | Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [108] |
157 | Swathirajan CR | 2017 | India | 829 | 19 | Modified acid-fast | 100.00% | NR | [147] |
158 | Ukwah BN | 2017 | Nigeria | 251 | 17 | PCR | 100.00% | 28.70% | [159] |
159 | Uysal HK | 2017 | Turkey | 115 | 3 | PCR, Ziehl-Neelsen | NR | NR | [163] |
160 | Yang Y | 2017 | China | 46 | 2 | Modified acid-fast | NR | NR | [180] |
161 | Yang Y | 2017 | China | 14 | 3 | Modified acid-fast | NR | NR | [181] |
Abbreviations: ELISA: Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay, IFA: Immunofluorescence Assay, PCR: Polymerase Chain Reaction, NR: not reported.
Current usage metrics show cumulative count of Article Views (full-text article views including HTML views, PDF and ePub downloads, according to the available data) and Abstracts Views on Vision4Press platform.
Data correspond to usage on the plateform after 2015. The current usage metrics is available 48-96 hours after online publication and is updated daily on week days.
Initial download of the metrics may take a while.